Test yourselves to see whether you are in the faith. Examine yourselves. Or do you yourselves not recognise that Jesus Christ is in you? – unless you fail the test. — 2 Corinthians 13:5 (CSBA)
This verse is often cited as a proof text for promoting self-examination as a requirement for assurance of salvation. Believers are frequently exhorted to look inward, searching for subjective signs of regeneration or sanctification, lest they be found wanting. Yet a careful reading, sensitive both to the immediate context and the broader Pauline corpus, demonstrates that this interpretation is misplaced.
The rhetorical structure of Paul’s argument
Paul writes these words toward the close of his second canonical letter to the Corinthians, a letter marked by tension and confrontation. Some in Corinth had called into question Paul’s apostolic authority, demanding “proof that Christ is speaking in [him]” (2 Cor 13:3). The apostle’s response is subtle but firm: he redirects their gaze. Instead of continuing to defend himself, he invites them to examine their own status: “Examine yourselves … Test yourselves.”
This is a rhetorical inversion. The proof of Paul’s apostleship lies in the very existence of the Corinthian church. They themselves, having received the gospel from Paul, are living evidence that Christ has been active through his ministry (cf. 1 Cor 9:2). Thus, Paul is not proposing an individualistic, subjective test of assurance but a corporate reminder of their origin in apostolic proclamation.
“In the faith” as corporate identity
The expression “whether you are in the faith” (εἰ ἐστὲ ἐν τῇ πίστει) should not be construed as a reference to the individual’s subjective experience of trust or perseverance. Instead, it signifies participation in the Christian faith as an objective sphere. As it is written elsewhere, believers are those who “hold fast the confession of our hope without wavering” (Heb 10:23), not because their grip is strong but because the content of their confession is true. The question is whether they stand within the faith community, defined by adherence to the gospel.
This distinction matters: Paul’s exhortation is not intended to cultivate introspective anxiety but to highlight the Corinthians’ collective identity. If they recognise themselves as believers—and they surely do—this serves as sufficient proof that Christ has been working through Paul’s ministry.
Christ in you
Paul continues: “Or do you not realise this about yourselves, that Jesus Christ is in you?” The rhetorical force is clear. The indwelling presence of Christ is an axiom of Pauline theology (cf. Gal 2:20; Col 1:27). Paul assumes that the Corinthians would affirm this reality. The irony is deliberate: while they question Paul’s authority, their very acknowledgement that Christ indwells them confirms both their salvation and, by extension, Paul’s legitimacy as an apostle.
“Unless you fail the test”
The phrase “unless indeed you fail to meet the test” (εἰ μήτι ἀδόκιμοί ἐστε) expresses a theoretical possibility rather than a genuine doubt. Paul does not suggest that the Corinthians have failed; in the following verse he expresses confidence that they will “know that we are not disqualified” (v. 6). His language simply acknowledges a hypothetical scenario for rhetorical effect. The underlying assumption remains that the Corinthians are genuine believers.
The theological significance
This passage has often been employed to promote the idea that assurance of salvation depends on self-examination and the discovery of subjective evidences of grace. Such a use misreads the text and dislocates assurance from its proper foundation: the promises of God and the finished work of Christ. Scripture teaches that believers may know they possess eternal life because of the testimony of God’s Word (1 John 5:13), not because they detect sufficient signs of sanctification in themselves.
Furthermore, Paul’s consistent teaching is that believers are secure in Christ (Rom 8:1; Eph 1:13–14). Their perseverance is grounded in divine faithfulness, not human performance (1 Cor 1:8–9). Therefore, to transform 2 Corinthians 13:5 into an exhortation to perpetual introspection is to turn the text against itself and to obscure Paul’s pastoral intent.
Conclusion
Paul’s exhortation in 2 Corinthians 13:5 is best understood as part of his defence of his apostolic ministry. The Corinthians’ own identity as believers—as those “in the faith”—is itself the proof they demand. Far from instructing Christians to seek assurance through self-scrutiny, Paul assumes that they will recognise the reality of Christ’s indwelling presence and, through that recognition, affirm the legitimacy of his ministry.
This reading not only fits the immediate context but also aligns with the broader scriptural witness: assurance is grounded in the objective promises of God and the sufficiency of Christ’s work, not in the shifting sands of human self-assessment.
Leave a Reply